Shropshire Live

Your local news & entertainment website and radio station

HomeNewsBusinessEntertainmentFeaturesWhat's OnAdvertisingRadioContact
Chris Molloy

ON AIR NOW: 6AM–8AM

Chris Molloy

Waking up Shropshire at the weekend it's Chris Molloy with the latest Shropshire news and entertainment.

Phil Shieber

NEXT UP: 8AM–12PM

Phil Shieber

The latest local news, sport and what's happening around the county.

Chris Molloy

Waking up Shropshire at the weekend it's Chris Molloy with the latest Shropshire news and entertainment.

Shropshire Council wins taxi signage court case

By Shropshire Live23 April 2012
Share
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp

Shropshire Council has won a court case after magistrates backed a decision taken in line with national guidelines to help people to distinguish between Hackney carriage taxis and private hire vehicles.

Shropshire Council wins taxi signage court case

At Shrewsbury Magistrates Court on Tuesday 10 April 2012, Central Cars Ltd challenged the council’s policy which requires private hire vehicles to display clear signage on the side of the vehicle, rather than having roof signs. Hackney carriage vehicles are permitted to have roof signs.

Central Cars Ltd lost its appeal to be permitted to keep roof signs, and therefore be exempt from the policy. Central Cars owner, Carl Wilday, was ordered to pay the council £1,000 in costs.

The signage conditions were agreed by the council’s Strategic Licensing Committee last year in accordance with guidance from the Department of Transport (DfT), which states that having roof signs on private hire vehicles is not best practice. Legislation also requires that private hire vehicles must differ in appearance from Hackney carriages.

The DfT guidance outlines that it is important that people are able to distinguish between the two types of vehicle to minimise confusion, particularly on the differences in how journeys are arranged. Private hire vehicles must be pre-booked.

Hackney carriage vehicles do not have to be pre-booked and can be hailed on the street. Anyone taking a journey in a private hire vehicle which has been ‘flagged down’ is not insured for the journey.

During the case the council pointed out that, despite some initial concerns, other private hire operators had told the council that they found not having roof signs to be beneficial for reasons including people no longer attempting to flag them down.
Furthermore, in major cities such as Manchester, Birmingham and Liverpool, the local authorities took the same approach of not allowing roof signs on private hire vehicles.

Steve Charmley, Shropshire Council’s Cabinet member with responsibility for licensing, said:

“This is a great result, coming shortly after another case won by the council which upheld a decision to refuse to grant a taxi licence because the applicant would not be operating mostly in the county.

“This again shows that our policy and decision-making is robust and taken in the best interests of the public. This case reinforces the importance of clarifying the differences between the two types of vehicle and the reasons why this policy is in place.”

Councillor Rosanna Taylor-Smith, chair of the Strategic Licensing Committee, said:

“The policy was agreed after establishing a task and finish group to develop the conditions and consulting widely on them.

“We are pleased that the courts have supported our approach, and reaffirmed that this is the best way forward in protecting the public and contributing to an effective transport system within the Shropshire Council area.”

  • Shrewsbury
  • Shropshire Council
FacebookTwitter / XInstagramYouTube
NewsBusinessEntertainmentWhat's OnFeaturesPremium FeaturesRadioAboutAdvertisingContact

Download the app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Privacy PolicyCookie PolicyTerms of UseCompetition TermsImpress Regulation
Shropshire Live is regulated by IMPRESS

© 2026 Shropshire Live. All rights reserved.  |  Designed and built by Shoothill

More from Shropshire Live

This is a test
News

This is a test

28 Sept 2026

Telford MP joins discussion on improving support for unpaid carers of seriously ill children
News

Telford MP joins discussion on improving support for unpaid carers of seriously ill children

Last week Shaun joined Telford & Wrekin CVS to host an event bringing unpaid carers together to have their say in the Government's Make Work Pay consultation before it closes on 1 September.

30 Jul 2026

Dyslexia Awards return in 2026 to celebrate exceptional talent and innovation
Features

Dyslexia Awards return in 2026 to celebrate exceptional talent and innovation

The prestigious Dyslexia Awards are set to make their grand return to Shropshire this year, spotlighting the remarkable achievements of dyslexics.

9 Jun 2026

Award-winning Newport Show promises finest food, music, and family fun
Entertainment

Award-winning Newport Show promises finest food, music, and family fun

Fantastic free fun, fine food and a festival feel are set to make this year’s Newport Show a great day out for all ages.

9 Jun 2026

Featured Articles

Go Carz go the extra mile throughout pandemic
Premium Features

Go Carz go the extra mile throughout pandemic

Shropshire’s largest taxi and private hire vehicle operator Go Carz has been working relentlessly over the last 12 months to ensure driver partners and their passengers have been able to travel safely throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.

25 Mar 2021

Popular Articles

  1. 1Telford MP joins discussion on improving support for unpaid carers of seriously ill children
  2. 2Telford & Wrekin Council opens consultation on Local Plan modifications
  3. 3Shropshire Council continues to explore opportunities to work with town and parish councils
  4. 4Former boss of luxury spa to head up Newport’s newest retirement village
  5. 5Shrewsbury College student designs trophies for county business awards